For companies

Commission-only vs salary vs agency

Salary, a sales agency, a fractional sales lead or commission-only reps: compared by when you pay, who carries the risk and what each needs from you.

By Olaf, FounderPublished Updated 7 min read

In this guide8 sections
  1. Commission-only vs salary vs agency vs fractional, at a glance
  2. Hiring a salaried sales rep
  3. Working with a sales agency
  4. Bringing in a fractional sales lead
  5. Working with commission-only sales reps
  6. Which one fits your stage?
  7. Mixing the models
  8. Questions to decide it

There are four common ways to pay for B2B sales: hire a salaried rep, pay an outside sales agency, bring in a fractional sales lead, or work with commission-only reps. They’re usually compared on cost. The more useful comparison is timing: when the money leaves your account, and what you have to show for it at that point.

  • Salary: from day one, before the first deal.
  • Agency: from the first month, usually as a retainer, before the first deal.
  • Fractional sales lead: from the first month, for part of someone’s week, before the first deal.
  • Commission-only: when a deal closes.

None of them is free. Commission-only moves the cost to after the revenue, which is why it suits a company that can’t fund months of selling before a pipeline exists. But it asks something else of you instead. This guide compares the four honestly, so you can pick the one that fits where your company is now.

Commission-only vs salary vs agency vs fractional, at a glance

Salaried repSales agencyFractional sales leadCommission-only rep
When you payEvery month, from the startUsually monthly, often plus success feesEvery month, for agreed daysWhen a deal closes, or when it’s paid
What you pay forTheir timeCapacity and a processSenior time, part of the weekResults
Who carries the risk of no salesYouMostly youYouMostly the rep
Control over how they workHighAgreed in the contractAgreed in the contractLow: they’re independent
What they need from youManagement, onboarding, a planA brief, feedback, materialAccess, decisions, a budgetAn offer worth betting on
Time to get startedWeeks to months to hireWeeks to onboardWeeksAs soon as a rep says yes

Exact costs vary by country, seniority and provider, so this guide doesn’t put prices on them. Get real quotes for your own market.

Hiring a salaried sales rep

A salaried rep, usually with a base salary plus commission, works for you and only for you. You decide their priorities, their territory, their process and their week.

When it works: you have a sales motion that already repeats. You know who buys, why, and roughly how many conversations it takes to close one. A salaried rep can then run that motion at full time, and you can manage and coach them.

What it costs you: the salary from the first day, plus the employer’s costs that come with employment where you are, plus the time to hire, which may include a recruiter’s fee when someone is hired. Then a ramp-up period before they close anything. If the hire doesn’t work out, notice periods and the cost of starting over.

The trade-off: you pay for certainty of effort, not certainty of results. A good salaried rep in a market that isn’t ready still closes nothing, and you still pay.

Working with a sales agency

An outsourced sales agency sells on your behalf with its own people and process. Agencies vary a lot: some book meetings for you, some run the whole cycle, some combine a monthly retainer with fees per meeting or per deal.

When it works: you need capacity quickly, you can afford a monthly fee while the pipeline builds, and you’d rather not hire and manage salespeople yourself.

What it costs you: a retainer, usually, plus any success fees, from the first month. Before you sign, ask who will actually work on your account, how many other clients they work for, and what you own at the end: the contacts, the notes, the scripts.

The trade-off: an agency is selling many products. Yours gets a share of its attention, and the relationships it builds may leave with it when the contract ends.

Bringing in a fractional sales lead

A fractional sales lead is an experienced sales leader who works for you part of the week, often for several companies at once, on a monthly fee. “Fractional” means you buy a fraction of a senior person rather than a whole one.

When it works: you need someone to build the sales process: the ideal customer, the pitch, the pipeline stages, the first hires or reps. You can’t justify a full-time head of sales yet, and you’d rather not make every sales decision yourself.

What it costs you: a monthly fee from the start, whether or not deals close, for a few days a week or month. Ask what they’ll do themselves and what they’ll set up for others to do: some sell themselves, others mostly build and manage.

The trade-off: a fractional lead brings judgement, not capacity. They can design the motion and hire for it, but one person on two days a week won’t run a full pipeline. Pair one with reps who do the selling, salaried or commission-only.

Working with commission-only sales reps

A commission-only rep is independent. They earn a share of the deals they close, nothing else, and they usually choose how, when and often what else they sell.

When it works: your product already sells (someone has closed deals), a typical deal is big enough to make the commission worth a rep’s time, the sales cycle is one a rep can wait out, and you can describe the offer with real numbers.

What it costs you: commission when a deal closes or is paid, and the work of writing an offer good enough for an experienced rep to bet on: a clear rate and base, a payout trigger, an honest cycle, leads or a reachable market. You also give up control. An independent rep isn’t an employee you can direct day to day; how the arrangement is set up has legal consequences that depend on the country, so check with your lawyer.

The trade-off: a rep paid only on results stays only for an offer where results are reachable. Commission-only isn’t a cheaper version of a hire. It’s a different deal, and it has to be a good one.

Which one fits your stage?

A rough guide, by where you are:

  • Nobody has sold it yet. Sell it yourself first. No model fixes a product that nobody has bought, and a commission-only rep shouldn’t be asked to find that out for free.
  • A few deals, founder-led. Commission-only fits well: you can describe who bought and why, and you can’t yet justify a full salary. Test it with one or two reps in a market you understand.
  • A repeatable motion and a budget. A salaried rep makes sense. You can manage them, and the predictability is worth the fixed cost.
  • Capacity needed quickly, with budget, and no one to manage reps. An agency can bridge it, if you check who does the work.
  • Selling works, but nobody owns the process. A fractional sales lead can build it, and the reps who’ll run it.

They also mix. A salaried head of sales can work with commission-only reps in new territories. A company can pay a small retainer plus commission to a rep it wants more commitment from. If you do mix, keep each arrangement written down and distinct, so nobody is unsure what they’re paid for.

Mixing the models

You don’t have to pick one model for every market or every stage. A few combinations are common, and each works best when the parts are kept clearly apart:

  • A small retainer plus commission. For a rep you want more of: a fixed number of hours, a territory held for you, regular reporting. The retainer buys commitment; the commission still pays for results. Write down what the retainer covers, or it slowly turns into a salary without the management.
  • A fractional lead with commission-only reps. The fractional lead writes the offer, screens the reps and runs the weekly pipeline call; the reps sell on commission.
  • A salaried lead with commission-only reps. One person employed to run the motion you know works, and independent reps opening new territories or industries you haven’t tested.
  • An agency for meetings, a rep for closing. An agency books first calls, and a commission-only closer runs the deals. Agree in advance who gets paid for a deal that both touched.

Whatever the mix, each person should be able to say in one sentence what they’re paid for and when.

Questions to decide it

Before you choose, answer these for yourself:

  1. How many months of selling can you fund before the first deal?
  2. Can you describe a typical deal: its size, its cycle, who signs it?
  3. Who will bring the leads?
  4. How much control do you need over how your product is sold?
  5. Who on your side will support whoever sells: answer questions, join calls, send material?

If you can answer the second and third questions with numbers, you’re ready to try commission-only. The next step is the offer, and the guide on how to hire commission-only sales reps covers it in order. On Upside Reps you can post a listing free, there is no fee per application, and the commission itself goes from you to the rep directly.

Keep reading